January 14, 2010

Fish and Health: More to the Story

Dave Love

Dave Love

Associate Scientist, Public Health & Sustainable Aquaculture Project

Johns Hopkins Center for a Livable Future

Iā€™d like to expand a little on my recent interview for a CNN piece by Elizabeth Landau entitled ā€œFarmed or wild fish: Which is healthier?ā€

At face value, this question can partialy be answered by comparing the nutritional content in farmed and wild fish and weighing the health benefits of fish consumption against the risks of pollutants present in fish. The Institute of Medicine of the National Academies has expertly covered this topic in Seafood Choices: Balancing Benefits and Risks, and authorities like Dr. Charles Santerre, have produced an excellent seafood consumer guide (Fish for Your Health wallet card) based on Omega-3 fatty acids, mercury and PCBs in fish. These comprehensive benefit-risk analyses and consumer-friendly information are useful and important contributions, though focus solely on human health.

interconnections1

In any discussion of seafood, it is also important to consider the negative impacts of fish farming or wild-caught fishing can have on the environment. These environmental impacts are considered as the basis for progressive fish certification schemes (examples: Friends of the Sea or Marine Stewardship Council) and consumer recommendation lists (example: Monterey Bay Aquarium wallet card) (read more). Sustainability should be an important consumer consideration, though in these certification schemes and consumer guidance materials, human health considerations are often absent.


There is a third perspective endorsed by the Johns Hopkins Center for A Livable Future (CLF) and others, which acknowledges the complex interrelationships among diet, food production, environment and human health. We are inextricably connected to our food systems and the environment, and by treating the natural world with respect ā€“ especially in regards to our diet – we can realize long-term health and ecological benefits. Polluting the environment, irresponsible practices in fish farming or overuse of fisheries can hurt humans in ways we may forget or not know to consider. Two examples of these complex linkages for seafood are:

  • Human produced environmental pollutants such as persistent organic pollutants (POPs), PCB, PBDEs, dioxins, and methylmercury can concentrate in wild-caught and farmed fish as they eat smaller polluted fish (ex: salmon, Hites et al., 2004). A recent study had linked POPs, at levels present in some farmed Altlantic salmon, with insulin resistance and associated obesity and liver disease in rats (Ruzzin et al., 2009).
  • Antibiotic use in fish farming promotes antibiotic-resistant bacteria in fish (Furushita et al., 2003), a phenomenon that mirrors industrial terrestrial food animal production (Aubry-Damon et al., 2004) and is a potential cause of increased community associated antibiotic-resistant infections in humans (Gilchrist et al., 2007).

Connecting food production, the environment, and human health is a daunting task, and requires looking at issues from many angles at once. My complements to the CNN author, Elizabeth Landau, for introducing a range of environmental and food systems topics into her article on seafood, and beginning to explore alternative connections between seafood and public health.

– Dave Love

17 Comments

  1. It’s always such a joy to read posts created by actual professionals.
    I am fed up with all that no-name, ghostwritten articles.
    That is why it was so wonderful to look at a compelling piece.
    I visit the writer has floor knowledge it the subject as well
    as some practical experience. This sort of information is
    more favorable than copypasted blog articles thoughts.

  2. I visit the author has ground knowledge it the topic as well as some practical experience.
    Such kind of information is more favorable than copypasted blog
    articles thoughts.

  3. Well, this material has just blown my mind! Therefore many intriguing facts and critical instances that I’m astonished
    and extremely satisfied with the information you
    provide us. The subject is burning as well, therefore
    I indicate I’ll read it two. Last but not the least is I can share this info with buddies of mine and get their pleasure
    from the given substance as well. Allow such advice be!

  4. Pingback: Expository Essay Outline Descriptive Of Person Example Guide To Write Winning Writing – Auto Services Website Design & Online Marketing

  5. Pingback: Public YarnFirm Communications - Transworld Freight Services

  6. Pingback: How to Cite a Poem: The Ultimate MLA Information Style Guide | Learn Technology With Websofttechs For Free

  7. Pingback: Neat way of writing capital H, similar to lower-case h – New Orleans Style Seafood

  8. Pingback: Let's Get Writing! - Top Gadget Spot

  9. Pingback: How to Approach AP World History: Modern DBQs – My Blog

  10. Pingback: Cursive Committal to writing Will No Longer Be Taught in Schools Because It’s a Big, Old Waste of Time – New Orleans Style Seafood

  11. Pingback: Dantes Legacy: Kinship between Languages in Seamus Heaneys Poetics – Tailor Game

  12. Pingback: Emily Dickinson and her aid of death and the afterlife in poetry - Lit bibliographies - in Harvard style - TOEFL vs IELTS

  13. Pingback: CONTINUE TO BILLING/PAYMENT – New Orleans Style Seafood

  14. Pingback: R Sound writing alphabet worksheets – Tailor Game

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*